Pelfrey

Another start, another 6 IP, >100 pitches, 3 ER. The guy's consistency is unbelievable; except for Trachsel, I've never seen anyone have the same line every time they pitched. Somehow he's just got to have a break-out game one of these times and get through the hurdle. One thing that's surprising to me is his K rate is so low: roughly 5 Ks/9 IP. I thought he was more of a strikeout pitcher?

Current Met Starters, Ranked by OPS

Wright 3B .875
Gotay 2B .850
Alou LF .831
Reyes SS .830
Beltran CF .823
[Milledge] .819
Delgado 1B .757
Green RF .725
LoDuca C .679
[Valentin] .676
[Gomez] .636

A few lessons:

1. Milledge is contributing in a very real way (basically hitting as well as Beltran) and should get 3rd OF playing time right now (between replacing Green against LHP and spelling Beltran and Alou).

2. Gotay has been hitting great, we all know that. There's a strong argument that his trade value might never be higher. There's also the chance he's Melvin Mora. My guess? Gotay & 2 pitching prospects (like Muniz, Schmoll, Burgos; not Pelfrey, Humber or Mulvey) will be offered for Mark Loretta.

3. As a team, we're underperforming. Even our better performers this year, Wright/Reyes/Beltran could be 50-150 points higher in their OPS. Delgado and Green are rally killers and non-producers at this point, and they both blow in the field.

4. Despite all the excitement Gomez produced, and all the callers from Bensonhurst who have annointed him the NEXT one, he clearly needs some more seasoning. As a PR/defensive replacement/spot starter he's fine already, but with his high ceiling, he needs to be playing every day and honing his eye and his situational hitting.

Joe Smith demoted

He's been hit hard recently, but still, I'm surprised. The details here.

I guess the thought is, with his velocity down and fatigue setting in, let him pitch through the dog days in AAA. Next year hopefully his endurance will be a little stronger. Still, it's not like he's the only guy in the bullpen who's been through a rough patch this year.

Kieth Kernandez called Billy Wagner...

the most dominant reliever the Mets have ever had in their organization, during last night's game broadcast. "I know it's only been a couple of seasons, but the Mets have never had a guy this good...".

Gary Cohen countered that for two months in 1973 McGraw was better, but that was a shorter period.

I figured SHK would appreciate...

Kunz signed

Our first round pick was signed 6 weeks after the CWS ended. He's big kid who throws hard and spent this past year closing for the team that ultimately won its second championship in a row. Apparently Omar is hoping he can be on the Joe-Smith-like fast track to the bigs. From Mets.com:

At Oregon State, Kunz helped lead his team to two consecutive College World Series championships. The 6-foot-5, 250-pounder went 3-1 with 12 saves this season as a closer for the Beavers. Last year, he held his spot as a setup man, and his freshman year he was a middle-man for the team.

For the Mets, Kunz will likely begin his career as a relief pitcher, general manager Omar Minaya said.

"We see him as definitely some type of relief pitcher," Minaya said. "We're not sure of what type that will be, but he'll find his place. That will take care of itself."

Kunz holds a fastball hovering around 95 mph, a changeup and a slider in his repertoire, and batters hit just .194 against him this season. He's had an outstanding college career, going 10-1 with a 2.87 ERA in 73 games, but knows that what lies ahead will be different, a challenge as he strives to earn his spot on a big-league roster.

"It's going to be a huge change for me, but I think I'll feel pretty comfortable and go out and settle in," Kunz said. "And hopefully, when I do get up here, it'll be a smooth transition for me."

It could take one year or it could take several. It's too early to tell, Minaya said, but Kunz will have his fair share of opportunities to show the club what he's got during his time in the Minors.

"Joe Smith did it in one year after he signed," Minaya said. "If you're a college player, it usually takes about four or five years, but he could be up here as early as September or August next year."

Teixeira

What would you be willing to give up for Teixeira? Better start thinking about it if you're Omar Minaya, since Rangers are apparently seriously looking to move him. Maybe we could set up a 3-way trade, where someone else takes Delgado, and we each give Texas a prospect in return. I'd be willing to put any of the following players on the block: Carp, Heilman, and probably Pelfrey.

Alou again

Not that I'm going to complain the way Milledge has been playing, but can someone please explain this to me??

With Moises Alou still on the disabled list - he was not activated yesterday because of a new ailment, a sore right shoulder...

How in the world do you get a sore right shoulder while sitting on your ass doing rehab??? This sounds like either: (a) a BS story and Alou's original injury is still a problem, or (b) Alou needs to figure out how to take better care of his old body.

Alou

Hopefully the return of Alou is the magic beans our offense has been searching for. We are currently #9 in NL in runs scored. Given our status as #1 in NL payroll that is pathetic. Time for the bats to start stepping up, and helping out our rotation.

Billy Billy Billy

I know it wasn't the playoffs, but last night was huge save for Wagner. The team mounts a gritty rally and finally grabs a one run lead after trailinig the whole game. If we give back the lead it's a crushing defeat: a comeback thwarted, a series win taken from them at the 11th hour, and a losing road trip. Instead, we got a stirring comeback, a series win against the Dodgers, and a winning road trip.

And what a tough way to do it. Billy picks Pierre off of 1st for what should have been the first out of the inning, but I think Greenie is still looking for that ball in his cavernous 1B mitt. Tying run in scoring position with 0 outs, and Wagner K's "the all star" Martin. IBB to Kent to face Kemp, a bold move considering the guy's hitting .360. Then Wagner K's Kemp. Finally, Nomar, who K's looking.

Talk about overcoming an error. Strikes out the side against the meat of the order, and three excellent contact hitters.

Valentin done for the year?

Apparently it's a possibility. That's a nasty injury.

Luckily, with the way Gotay's been hitting, playing him at second softens the blow somewhat. And you can platoon him with Easley so he doesn't feel too much pressure at one time.

I've been jealous that the Janks pulled Cano from their system just when the Mets needed a Cano type player, but in Gotay, we may have found one of our own. Emphasis on may.

Which leads to the million ten-thousand dollar question: do you trade Gotay, who suddently probably has some actual value, do bring in Loretta? Loretta's been rumored to be available, and you know Willie would really prefer to have the veteran stability and good glove that Loretta would bring (and his .300 average doesn't hurt either). So do you give up the young guy who's tearing it up (along with another prospect) in a small sample of AB's for the proven commodity who's in his 30's?

A few thoughts

1. Gotay's bat looks to be real.. Per DC's earlier post, I hope his glove is at least good enough to justify keeping him as a regular starter. We could use the average in our lineup.

2. Wright's BA improvement month-to-month has been nothing short of amazing: April (.244), May (.294), June (.323), July (.328). His combo of average + power is outstanding.

3. The strike zone has finally caught up to Glavine. He and Maddux used to drive me crazy when they were on the Braves, b/c I felt that if it weren't for the slightly wider strike zone they were always afforded, they'd be nothing. Don't get me wrong, their ability to control location so consistently is nothing short of spectacular. But, at the end of the day a ball is still a ball, no matter how perfectly you locate it. If Glavine isn't getting a wide zone, he's done.

4. I heard the Mets gave Pedro a one-week break from rehab, which some execs read to mean that he's not as on track as Mets would like. Any updates?

5. The '86 team finished with a remarkable .667 win %age. To put that into perspective, it would mean today's team at 53-42 is so far behind they would have to win their next 31 games in a row to get to that same win %, and close out the season 55-12 to finish up 108-54.

Recap

The bolded line below (emphasis mine) is about the funniest line I've ever seen in a recap.. Courtesy of metsgeek.com..

Bottom of the first and it’s time for John Maine to recover from his jittery outing against Cincinnati last week. Maine’s stuff looked good – the hitters were fouling it off to the opposite field, and he missed his usual share of bats. But he walked the leadoff hitter on five pitches, and one out later, Adrian Gonzalez hit a grounder just past the reach of the armoire playing first base. On a positive note, Shawn Green now offers same-day service on balls hit down the line, and he did hold Gonzalez to an RBI double.

Man, do the editors over at Geek ever hate Greenie!

Pads

I didn't see last night's game but checking out the box score makes you wonder. On the one hand, what an insult that El Duque was able to steal second! Are you kidding?? On the other hand, is that really the smartest play for a guy who is perenially injured now, to the point where he knocked himself out of the playoffs last year while lightly jogging around the outfield during warm-ups? Next, you can't be anything but thrilled that we smoked them 7-0 during a Peavy start - you know that is going to benefit us in the playoffs. On the other hand, how did Mets Offense 2.0 manage to strand 20 runners on base?

Baseball's an interesting game... Now let's take the rubber match tonight and move on to LA..

Heilman

It's time for Mets to trade Heilman. He is not going to be a good reliever, and I doubt we're ever going to let him be the starter he wants to be. Let's consider him tradeable as part of a package.

BTW, I'm sure glad we didn't roll the dice on free agent Gagne in the offseason like I had suggested last year. (insert sarcasm here.) Who needs a guy with 1.23 ERA, 0.92 WHIP, 2-0 w/14 SVs to 1 BLSV, at a cost of only $6 M for one season, without giving up any trades??? If we had taken a chance, we would now have the option of trading either Wagner or Gagne, both of who's stock is through the roof, and could've parlayed that into a meaningful starter. But it's a good thing we held onto that $6M instead. Otherwise how would we have paid Alou, Sanchez, Green, ...?

Mailbag

This question on mets.com was so absurd I couldn't help but laugh, and wonder why marty noble actually answered it. It can't have been a serious question, could it?

Because Endy Chavez made that great catch in Game 7 of the NLCS last year, could he go into the Hall of Fame just for that?
-- Jacob K., Croton, N.Y.

Humber and stuff

Unfortunately, Humber's #s don't seem particularly impressive yet (except for SO:BB ratio, looks reasonable at ~3.5:1), and his splits don't show any improvement from April to July. I would hope that Pelfrey and Humber develop into solid pitchers, especially given how hyped they have been. But at this point I haven't seen anything that tells me either one will be a truly great pitcher, a legit #1.

Any predictions on Pedro? Will he be as good in his return as he keeps talking himself up to be? Hard to imagine, but if so that would completely change the look of this team. His #s with the Mets in '05 and April of '06 were tremendous, and would give the rotation an enormous boost. His return to even a reasonable level would make an impact that can't be overstated.

Speaking of injuries, what's the word on Alou and Sanchez? I heard Alou's not back until August. What about Sanchez? Will either one return in form to contribute? If so, expect Mets to pull away from Braves.

Run at Dunn?

This kid is only 27 or so, and has massive power (the type that doesn't diminish just 'cause you play at Shea), and should have, conservatively another 4 good years in him. I figure him to have a short shelf life for a player, given his lumbering body type and long swing. The numbers are what they are. 40 HR's a possibility in any given year, but don't expect an average much above .250.

If Alou's not coming back this year (or is still a big question mark) at the time of the deadline, do you give this kid a look? I understand that the Reds might want to deal him for some younger talent, especially since it's a walk year for Dunn. If he fits in well here, you could extend him with an eye towards replacing Delgado. He's played 1b before.

Peflrey to the Pen

According to Mets.com, which means there's a 50/50 chance he's starting tomorrow.

But seriously, the article says he'll be in the pen until Sosa is reactivated, and then it's a question mark what the team will do. Would they keep up Pelfrey and demote/designate Sele or the Scho? I doubt it, but it's hard to argue Pelfrey couldn't pitch just as badly as those two, with a much higher ceiling. And it's a chance to keep him in the bigs. I'm not saying he couldn't benefit from more time on the farm, but the biggest obstacle he's facing right now seems to be his general fear level of facing ML hitters. He looks so nervous and uncomfortable on the mound, pacing, huffing, answering LoDuca before he's finished his sentence, etc. Enough armchair analysis for now.

Sometimes You're the Hero, Sometimes You're the Gotay...

Although I'm firmly in the camp of playing Ruben on an everyday basis (Valentin is turning to dust before our eyes) last night was an abomination.

This guy's got a worse glove than Ty Wigginton displayed at 2nd.

I still think he's the future at the position, barring the pickup of a proven vet (aka Mark Loretta?), but last night's travesty set him back a few notches in the eyes of the critics.

During the radio broadcast yesterday, Howie made a few comments on the Mets naming HoJo as the hitting coach and the reasons for the move. Apparently the idea is for HoJo to work with the younger players (specifically Wright, Reyes, and Gotay) to teach them about developing their approach at the plate and situational hitting--WHAT THE F??? These are the only guys in the lineup that can get a hit with men in scoring position and Wright and Reyes are top-ten in the league in walks. Once again, let's find what works and put the kibosh on it...

How about we make force some of the vets to put down the buffet plates and get into the cage for a bit. Yeah, I'm talking to you Beltran, Delgado, LoDuca, Valentin, and Green. These guys are the freakin' problem, not our young guns...

Interesting about face

Mets.com has a different story up now than before.

Time for some Rickey Hits

Followed up by some Rickey Steals and some Rickey Runs.

It's just Rickey being Rickey.

Rick down (& out)

Well, minaya clearly reads this blog b/c I've been calling rick down out for a long time now. Looks like Mets agree, since Down was canned and HoJo or Rickey Henderson is in. I think the Mets need to start having a team batting mentality, rather than purely individual, and I'd like to see a hitting coach who is clearly getting them to think about making in-game and even in-pitch adjustments. I believe both HoJo and Henderson are well respected enough by the players that they should listen to hitting strategy/advice from either of them. I think this will only help the offense.

Billy billy billy

Well, unable to screw us thus far in the regular season, wagner decided to save his best for the all-star game. By pulling a vintage wagner and giving up the bomb, he destroyed the Mets chances to have home-field advantage should they make it to WS. Well played billy, well played.

On the other hand, Jose Jose Jose did all he could, both at bat and in the field. What a game he had.

Milledge

This is promising:

Lastings Milledge is raking at Double-A Binghamton and could be recalled before too much longer. Milledge is 8-for-19 with a double, triple, homer, five runs and five RBIs after a 3-for-5 game yesterday.

"I'm sure by the time we get back from the [All-Star] break, he'll have a good six or seven games under his belt," Randolph said. "Then we'll look at it and see where he is."

With Alou out forever who knows how long, and green stinking, it would be great if milledge were ready to come back to majors. That will also put less pressure on gomez and allow him to keep developing in AAA.

2B (or not 2B)

Hate to have a post simply reference another site and contain no original content, but this wrap-up on Metsgeek was pretty funny so I thought worth copying here.

The only silver lining in this dark cloud of a game was that it provided Exhibit 45 in the case against Jose Valentin, who went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts, stranding six...He’s not hitting, which would be okay if the Mets had a stacked lineup and he was getting it done with the glove. But the Ol’ Gray Lineup, she ain’t what she used to be, and she can’t absorb another player whose on-base percentage is on the wrong side of .300. And Valentin’s defense is about as sharp as you’d expect from a 37-year-old playing with a leg brace.

Really, what more does Ruben Gotay have to do to win the job? He’s hitting .333 with pop, and he’s not doing it with bloops and bleeders – his line-drive percentage rate is 25%, says Fangraphs.com. He’s the only one on the team who seems aware that you’re allowed to foul off a two-strike pitch.

Beltran

Well, I'll give it up and say Beltran finally laid out for a catch. While not the all-out dive I'd like to see at some point from him, he certainly deserves credit for hauling ass up The Hill in houston and making the over-the-shoulder game-saving catch in the 14th. A great display of talent + hustle.

Maine

While it went by without comment, the only two of the last six games the Mets have won came with Maine on the mound. Over at MetsGeek, the daily recap boys had this to say:

Maine looks more and more like an old-school ace with every start. You need him to stop a losing streak? He’s there. Bullpen worn out? He’ll go eight. Defense lets him down with an error? He’ll bear down. Hitters leaning over the plate? Chin music time. He’s a white Bob Gibson, lacking only a Tim McCarver-style publicist.

Maine threw down the gauntlet immediately, striking out the side on 15 pitches in the first; he’d already missed more bats in 10 minutes than the rest of the Met rotation had in the prior four days. He struck out another pair in the second, and the Astros didn’t get a runner to second base through the first five. Dude.

Maybe a little much, but Maine's certainly elevating himself quickly.

Good for Willie

While Reyes is the best the Shortstop to ever grace a baseball diamond, he has been dogging it. For the second time in three games, he didn't even bother to run out a ground ball that turned out to be fair. Instead, he stood in the batters box last night, watching the Astros' 3B Lamb run a ground ball from the third base bag all the way over to near first base (where I think he made a short toss) while Jose Jose Jose looked on stupified. That was the third out of the inning, and Willie immediately pulled Reyes from the game.

"I won't tolerate that from anyone," Randolph said. "It doesn't matter who it is."

"If you can't get out of the box," Randolph said several times, "you don't play."

Reyes' quotes were a little less satisfactory:

"Yeah, I think the ball was going to be foul," Reyes said. "But we still have to run. That was my fault there.

"But that thing could happen to anybody. Hopefully it [doesn't] happen the next time."

Hopefully? Try this one Jose: if there's a chance it can be fair, just run. Then you won't need to hope.

Pelf

Now, I'm certainly not going to blame last night's L on Pelfrey. When the Mets only give up 4 runs and score 0, I have to hang that on their pathetic offense. But, I have to say that Pelfrey's remarkable Trachsel-like consistency is very worrisome. If his #s were up and down that would be one thing - but they aren't. EVERY one of his outings is exactly the same: 3 or 4 runs yielded in 5-6 innings with 100 pitches. Both the high pitch count, and the fact that he consistently pulls a trax and gives up exactly that number of runs in that number of innings is odd at best, worrisome at worst. I know he's got a pretty nasty arsenal of pitches, particular the heater, but I haven't seen any progress in how he uses them as well as his confidence.

Roster

Old players are killing us. They are either getting injured, or their career stats have hit a brick wall. Glavine, El Duque, Delgado, Green, Valentin, and Alou. Young players doing well: Reyes, Wright, Maine, Perez, and Sosa. I'm not sure what Beltran's excuse is, other than general suckiness.

And I hate to say I called it, but looks like indeed Mota's first season back after the juice is indeed an enormous bust.
(11/16/06) Mota's tougher, but I wouldn't be broken up to lose him. First, he's out for 50 games. Next, I have yet to see a player come off the juice and play well the following year. So he likely has a down year next year anyway.